How Retail Leadership Changes Influence Which Pet Brands Get Shelf Space

When a New Retail MD Walks In: Why Your Cat’s Favorite Food Can Suddenly Vanish (or Thrive)

It’s frustrating: one month the cat’s favorite wet food is on the shelf, the next it’s replaced by a new private label or pushed to an endcap behind a seasonal promotion. For families who rely on consistent brands for allergies, age-specific nutrition, or budget planning, these shifts feel arbitrary — but they’re not. Behind every product swap is a series of leadership choices, category metrics, and promotional strategies driven by retail executives.

The headline you may have seen in 2026 — and why it matters

In early 2026 Liberty promoted Lydia King, its group buying and merchandising director, to managing director of retail. That kind of promotion is more than a personnel change: it signals a possible re-prioritization of buying strategies, supplier relationships, and merchandising rules that directly affect which pet brands get national distribution, which SKUs are expanded, and which are cut.

"A change at the MD level at a large retail group is like changing course mid‑voyage. The ship doesn’t swivel overnight, but where it points next quarter can be very different."

Top-line: How leadership moves change shelf space — fast

Here are the immediate mechanisms by which a new retail leader influences the cat food aisle:

• Buying priorities reset: New MDs bring fresh strategic goals (margin first, premium growth, sustainability, or price leadership).
• Category reviews and rationalizations: Expect assortment reviews that add or cut SKUs according to new KPIs.
• Promotion calendar shifts: The kinds of promotions supported (everyday low price vs. heavy TPRs) change, altering which brands win visibility.
• Vendor portfolios rebalanced: Relationships may be reshuffled — favored suppliers gain distribution and co-op funds, while weaker partners lose shelf space.
• Planogram & merchandising changes: New directives can change how planograms allocate linear feet, endcaps, and feature bays.
• Digital shelf integration: With omnichannel leaders, online assortment choices influence in-store displays and vice‑versa.

Why 2026 is a critical year for shelf decisions

Several market forces that sharpened in late 2025 are now driving bolder assortment and distribution decisions in 2026:

• AI-driven category management: Retailers are using machine learning to model SKU-level profitability and test faster assortment changes.
• Sustainability and traceability: Retail buyers increasingly prioritize brands with verified ESG credentials and transparent supply chains.
• Private label acceleration: To protect margins during tight consumer spending, many retailers are expanding premium private-label pet lines.
• Omnichannel parity: Online analytics now directly influence physical shelf allocations — the "digital shelf" is a real driver of in-store space.
• Promotional fatigue and targeted offers: Loyalty-driven, personalized promotions are replacing mass flyers, changing which SKUs need in-aisle prominence.

Real-world example: What Lydia King's promotion could signal

While every executive is different, a promotion from group buying and merchandising director to retail MD — like Liberty’s Lydia King in January 2026 — often signals a few likely shifts:

• Stronger focus on vendor economics: Expect tighter scrutiny on margin per square foot and co-op effectiveness.
• More test-and-learn pilots: Merchandising veterans promoted to MD often expand pilots (regional exclusives, new planogram concepts) before national rollouts.
• Fewer low-velocity SKUs: A buyer with merchandising roots may accelerate SKU rationalization to reduce clutter and improve sales density.
• New vendor partnerships: Promotions often come with reboots of supplier relationships; brands seen as cooperative and data-ready gain priority.

Breaking down the buying decision: Metrics that matter

Retail buyers don’t make emotional decisions about brands. They use a tight set of metrics — and those metrics get re-weighted whenever leadership changes.

1. Sales velocity (units/day or per week) — high velocity wins more linear feet.
2. Margin contribution and gross profit per square foot — a perennial favorite when margins tighten.
3. Promotional lift and ROI on trade funds — buyers reward brands that fund successful promotions.
4. Out-of-stock frequency & supply reliability — a crucial 2026 filter after supply chain investments accelerated in 2023–25.
5. Customer feedback and loyalty signals — loyalty program purchase data and online reviews increasingly influence assortment.
6. Shelf-space productivity (sales per linear foot) — used to justify adding or removing SKUs.

How promotions change who gets noticed

Promotions are the lifeblood of retail discovery. In 2026, the form of promos is evolving — which means the winners are changing, too.

• From breadth to targeted depth: Mass price cuts are giving way to targeted digital coupons, BOGO offers for loyalty members, and paid-search pushes. Brands that can activate loyalty offers get repeat buyers and higher reorder rates — precisely what category managers want.
• Event-based merchandising: Retailers synchronize promos with calendar events (holiday pet campaigns, wellness weeks) and leaders set the agenda. A new MD can change the calendar and who gets the feature.
• Co-op and ad fund power: Brands with smarter co-op strategies and measurable ROI are more likely to be included in circulars and digital features.

What this means for pet brands: How to win shelf space after an executive change

If your brand depends on retail shelf presence, a leadership move like Liberty’s is an opportunity — not a crisis. Here are practical steps to proactively protect and grow in-aisle position:

1. Move fast to understand new priorities

• Monitor the new leader’s public statements, LinkedIn posts, and interviews to decode priorities (price, sustainability, local sourcing, or omnichannel integration).
• Request a short 15–30 minute strategy sync — frame it as a learning call, not a pitch.

2. Translate your value into the metrics buyers use

Provide a concise metrics pack that answers: How will this SKU affect sales velocity, margin/sq ft, shrink, and loyalty retention? Use actual store-level data where possible.

3. Offer pilot programs, not immediate rollouts

Recommend low-risk regional pilots with clear success measures (e.g., 12-week sales lift, conversion rates, repeat purchases). This aligns with a merchandising-driven MD who wants proof before national space allocation.

4. Be promotion-ready and data-enabled

• Fund initial promotions or targeted loyalty offers and commit to measuring ROI.
• Provide point-of-sale creatives and digital assets optimized for the retailer’s loyalty platform.

5. Demonstrate supply-chain reliability

Retailers penalize OOS — show safety-stock plans, forecast accuracy, and alternatives (e.g., regional warehousing). In 2026, being data-driven on supply equals credibility.

6. Build a sustainability or traceability story

If the new MD prioritizes ESG, be ready with verified claims, certifications, and supply-chain traceability. This is increasingly part of the shelf-space conversation.

What pet owners should do when brands disappear or shrink in-store

If your cat's food is at risk, you don’t have to accept scarcity. Here’s how to stay resilient and keep the food you trust in rotation.

1. Get proactive about buying

• Set up online subscriptions with the brand or a retailer — subscription demand can influence buyers.
• Order via the retailer’s online channel if it shows more SKUs than the local store.

2. Use store customer feedback channels

Ask the local store manager to put in a replenishment request or to flag the brand to category management. Retailers track customer requests and can use them during assortment reviews.

3. Join brand loyalty lists and community forums

Brands often share restock alerts and regional availability updates via mailing lists and social channels.

4. Know acceptable substitutes

Work with your vet to identify nutritionally equivalent alternatives before you have to make a sudden switch due to shelf changes.

How retailers can manage transitions with less customer friction

Changes in leadership don’t have to mean frustrated customers. Here are retailer best practices that forward-looking MDs are adopting in 2026:

• Transparent communication: Notify loyalty members about assortment trials and upcoming changes well in advance.
• Omnichannel parity: Keep online assortments aligned with store availability and clearly mark region-only SKUs.
• Phased assortment changes: Use pilots to remove low-performing SKUs only after testing customer reaction.
• In-aisle substitution guidance: Provide staff scripts and shelf tags with vetted substitutes for removed products (helps households with special-diet pets).

Advanced strategies: Using 2026 tech to secure (or regain) shelf presence

Retailers and brands that leverage modern tech stack win. Here are advanced tactics now mainstream in 2026:

• AI-driven assortment optimization: Present models that simulate demand and margin impacts of carrying your SKU by region and customer cohort.
• Shelf analytics & computer vision: Use real-time shelf-scanning data to prove in-store execution and opportunity gaps.
• Digital coupons tied to in-store lift: Use loyalty data to prove that your coupon drove footfall and incremental purchases.
• Traceability dashboards: Provide blockchain or verified data proving ingredient origin if sustainability is a retailer priority.

Quick checklist: What to do in the 90 days after an MD promotion

1. Research the new MD’s priorities and public statements.
2. Send a concise, metrics-driven one-pager tailored to those priorities.
3. Propose a short pilot with clear KPIs and a funded promotion.
4. Offer proof of supply reliability and contingency plans.
5. Be ready to provide creative assets and loyalty-targeted offers quickly.

Case studies & mini-profiles (anonymized lessons)

From 2024–2026 we saw several illustrative outcomes when retail leaders changed:

• Case A — Premium Private Label Push: A new retail MD focused on margin growth by expanding private label premium pet food. Two national brands lost linear feet but were offered regional pilot space tied to co-op funding — brands that accepted pilots regained distribution after proving velocity.
• Case B — Sustainability-First Reweight: After a retailer publicly prioritized ESG, brands with certified traceability gained endcap slots. Smaller brands that invested in verifiable sourcing quickly earned broader distribution.
• Case C — Omnichannel Rebalance: One retail group began allocating in-store space to items with strong digital conversion rates. Brands that optimized digital content and paid to be visible online saw better in-store placement.

Future predictions: Where shelf space decisions head in late 2026 and beyond

Based on 2025–2026 trends, expect these longer-term dynamics:

• Faster assortment churn: AI-backed simulation tools will shorten the feedback loop, so retailers will test new SKUs more frequently.
• Hyper-localized assortments: Regional flavor and local-brand emphasis will expand as retailers tailor stores to communities with predictive analytics.
• Subscription-driven space: Brands with strong subscription demand will earn strategic shelf positions because they improve lifetime value and predictability.
• Shared metrics across channels: Retailers will require vendors to report unified performance metrics across digital and physical channels.

Actionable takeaways — what cat-food brands, retailers, and pet parents should do now

• Brands: Act quickly after leadership moves: offer low-risk pilots, submit a data-first pitch, and align promotions with the new MD’s stated priorities.
• Retailers: Communicate changes clearly, use pilots to reduce customer pain, and rely on digital-to-store metrics when reallocating space.
• Pet parents: Subscribe where possible, request the product at your local store, and use loyalty channels — consumer signals matter in assortment decisions.

Final thoughts

Executive promotions like Liberty’s appointment of Lydia King are not cosmetic. They are strategic inflection points that reweight how retailers value suppliers, structure promotions, and allocate precious shelf real estate. For brands, the moment presents a chance to reset relationships and earn new distribution by speaking the buyer’s language: metrics, pilots, and measurable promotional ROI. For shoppers, awareness and small actions — subscriptions, replenishment requests, and loyalty engagement — can make the difference between seeing your cat’s food on the shelf or finding a substitute.

Call to action

If you’re a brand manager ready to build a tailored 90‑day retail playbook after an executive change, or a pet parent who wants alerts when your brand is back in stock, we can help. Contact our Product Catalog team for a custom retailer briefing, pilot templates, and shopper communication scripts built for 2026’s retail realities.

Related Reading

• Audit for the AI Era: Adding Digital PR, Social Signals, and Entity Checks to Your SEO Checklist
• How to Host an Art Auction Pizza Night (and Raise Funds Like a Gallery)
• Model-Backed Betting Content: How Sports Sites Use 10,000-Simulation Models (and How Creators Can Too)
• How Spiking Metals Prices Could Push Inflation Higher — and What Traders Are Doing
• Small-Space Gym Gallery: Motivational Prints for Home Workout Setups